Showing posts with label photography rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label photography rights. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 June 2015

Creators working together?


I have been reading with great interest the open letter sent by Taylor Swift to Apple in response to their very generous offer of giving away other peoples work for free (musicians work that is), and how Apple have done a very sensible about turn in the face of mass public pressure (no one wants to look bad in front of their customer base)  To Apple Love Taylor

 
Even greater interest for me was the second open letter written by my friend Jason Sheldon, a successful and skilled concert Photographer, in which he publishes the 'Concert Photo Authorisation form' that all photographers have to sign before they can photograph Ms Taylor in action for their publications.

Ms Taylor's contract demands access to all the photographers concert photos for free, not just for three months as Apple had intended with Ms Taylor's work.








Of course to music and concert photographers this kind of rights grab will not be a novelty. I have a personal collection of scores of these unfair contracts. Some go as far as to demand ownership of work done, and even to demand that the photographer then indemnify the band group for any losses they incur,  and most insist on ownership (copyright) of the photographs for the band to do with as they will - all of course at the expense of the photographer who is not allowed to use or licence the images he or she has worked so hard to get.


As a result of these 'sign and give away your work and rights' or 'don't sign and don't take photograph' contracts I have largely pulled out of  concert photography.  Too many times, I have arrived at the venue, sometimes after travelling several hours to be presented with a contract that has to be signed at the door of the venue minutes before the performance commences.   Not even the common decency to send out the contract when the access has been confirmed by e-mail. Clearly, those issuing these contracts know they are unfair, so they issue them only when the photographer is under the most pressure - as they are about to go into the gig. No chance to get them vetted legally etc.





Interestingly enough the Independent followed up Sheldon's piece with a response from Taylor Swifts 'people'. In the piece:

"Swift's UK spokesperson has now responded with the following statement: "The standard photography agreement has been misrepresented in that it clearly states that any photographer shooting 'The 1989 World Tour' has the opportunity for further use of said photographs with management's approval."

Ok, yes it does, but I wonder how easy or difficult that permission would be to get? From Firefly? Swifts management team, I wonder how many photographers have received such permission easily and quickly without any kind of hassle?

It goes on:

""Another distinct misrepresentation is the claim that the copyright of the photographs will be with anyone other than the photographer - this agreement does not transfer copyright away from the photographer."

Actually there was no such misrepresentation, What Sheldon actually says is:

" it appears to be a complete rights grab"

 And that it is; and it goes on and demands that you are granted free and unlimited use of our work, worldwide, in perpetuity..  Now that isn't a transfer of copyright, but no one ever said it was. Perhaps Taylor's UK representative simply does not understand copyright?

She could revise it here Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988

Of course swifts UK representative total omits to deal with the fact that the agreement  demands that you are granted free and unlimited use of our work, worldwide, in perpetuity. And Swift wasn't happy  (quite rightly) with Apple taking only three months!!!

 But we are told the agreement has been updated. Yes, yes it has. If anything it is even worse...




 I would draw your attention dear reader to paragraph 3:

"On behalf of yourself and the Publication, you expressly grant FEI, and its related entities, including, but not limited to 13 Management, LLC; Taylor Nation, LLC; and Taylor Swift Productions, Inc. (the “Related Entities”), the perpetual, worldwide right to use the published Photographs for any non-commercial purpose (in all media and formats), including but not limited to publicity and promotion on their web sites and/or social media accounts or pages."

 There it is again free use for ever and a day, and this includes publicity and promotion (generally regarded in the industry as Commercial use by the way)


And Paragraph 5 is good too:

"If you fail to fully comply with this Authorization, authorized agents of FEI, the Artist or the Related Entities may confiscate and/or destroy the technology or devices that contain the master files of the Photographs and other images, including, but not limited to, cell phones and memory cards, and the Photographs and any other images; and eject you from the venue, in addition to any other remedy available to FEI, Artist and/or the Subjects. You and the Publication jointly and severally shall indemnify and hold FEI, the Artist, the Related Entities and the Subjects harmless from and against any and all claims, losses, injury,
damage, and expenses incurred by any or all of them arising out of this Authorization and/or the undersigned’s attendance at the Concert. You and the Publication hereby release FEI, Artist, the Related Entities, their officers, directors, employers, contractors, and agents, and the Subjects from and against any and all liability arising out of this authorization and/or your attendance at the Concert"


They give themselves permission to confiscate or destroy?  Even the police are not allowed to do that!!

This has to be one of the worst band agreements I have ever seen. Compare it to the reasonable one I refer to later in this blog.

Taylor Swifts Management Company Firefly are not the only ones who try and restrict Photographers to a point where covering the band is simply uneconomic. The well known and popular singer Kylie Minogue's management company Darenote Limited go a step further and demand that the photographer assign copyright. (see note 2.)



"We shall own and you hereby assign to us the copyright in and to the Photographs"


As if it makes it all OK then say  (note 3):

"We shall not exploit the photographs in any manner without your consent"

(By this they mean they can use the images for their own use, but will not in anyway sell them on or licence them to third parties)

But then confusingly go onto say (note 4) 

"We shall be entitled to assign transfer sub-license mortgage charge or otherwise dispose of our rights hereunder to any person or entity without reference to you."

Wow.  Now that is a real rights grab!!!


What has probably not been made clear to the reader so far; indeed I don't believe it has been mentioned in any discussion of band-photographer contracts, is that the photographer does not get these 'contact or agreements' in advance of the show. No! In every circumstance I have experienced, and in every circumstance that fellow photographers tell me of, these contracts are handed to the photographer as they are about to enter the venue, and always on a 'sign or you don't get to photograph' basis.  If the photographer queries the legality of the document - we all do, then of course there is no way of discussing or negotiating a change as the venue staff have no control or jurisdiction. The answer is always:

"We have been told sign or no photographs!"

Does that sound right? 
Does it sound fair?  
Does it come across as a legitimate way to do business?

If a photographer is employed, then he or she is being asked to sign a legal document that in all probability they have no authorisation to sign, and without the publications legal department having the option to look at it. Also without the option of discussion.

If, as most are, the photographer is either a sole trader, or a self employed person asked to attend the concert by a publication, then the situation is worse. Not only do they not have the authorisation to sign on behalf of a publication, but inevitably they are dependent on selling the photos to their client in order to earn that day.  Travelling seventy miles to a gig, and then being presented with a legal looking document that you can't possibly sign is not good for your average freelance.  If they do decide to sign and cover the gig then there is only the one reproduction fee from the initial client - the photographer then has no control of their clients (or their own) future use of their own created work.

Or worse still, the photographer doesn't sign, doesn't get paid, and can't even recover the expenses (mileage etc).



Fortunately, such restrictive contracts or agreements are still comparatively rare, and only a small percentage of bands issue them. But that percentage is increasing!


Bands are keen to protect the commercial exploitation of their image - marketing t-shirts, gifts, memorabilia and suchlike, and they have every right to do so. 

Photographers and bands/musicians should work together in this. 
No images = nothing to exploit of course. 
But it should be working together not one party cynically exploiting the other - as Apple initially intended.

  So what would a reasonable agreement look like you want to know?  I am glad you asked because I happen to have one here...



Nothing here to make anyone's eyes water. Protects the artist - ensures that the editorial photographer does not sell on photographs to competing commercial concerns etc, and protects the photographer too, by ensuring that there aren't any of those nasty rights grabs, demands for free pictures or control of reproduction.



What about outside music?


As many photographers will be able to tell you, unfair contracts are not limited to bands and music.

Editorial photographers all over the UK, (actually the world), are getting clobbered by unfair work conditions in the form of over zealous contracts, and inevitably they are presented as - 'sign or don't work'.

When Johnston Press made so many of its staff photographers redundant, and offered to take some of them back on as freelance workers, there seemed to be little in it for the photographers. They lost the security of their paid job, company vehicle, company equipment, paid holidays, sick pay and simply found themselves being asked to do the same job for less money, a lot more expense, and they were still expected to sign away they rights to their own work!


     "You irrevocably waive any rights that you have or may in future be entitled to under the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 and any other moral rights to which you may be entitled under any legislation now existing or in future enacted in any part of the world, in respect of the work provided by you"



Barcroft Media (an international media content company based in London, England.) made this part of an agreement with contributing photographers:


"Photographer agrees to work for Barcroft as an independent contractor, providing photography-related services upon assignment from Barcroft.   Photographer agrees to transfer all photographs to Barcroft immediately upon completion of an assignment. Photographer further agrees not to sell any image taken during the contracted event to any other person or business without Barcroft’s express written permission."  
and


"All of Photographer’s work while on assignment for Barcroft will be considered work-for-hire under the United States Copyright Act of 1976.  All photographs and images, inclusive of electronic files and other materials related to them, are the property of Barcroft."

Work for Hire is of course a US phenomenon, and under UK law the photographer is still regarded as a freelance and therefore retains copyright. To demand copyright in this aggressive manner is totally counter to the spirit and legality of the UK's Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988


 A National Magazines contract also has a rights grab as one of its main clauses:

"ALL RIGHTS" means National Magazine acquires the entire worldwide copyright in the material and all other intellectual property rights in the material for all uses including but not limited to all rights to use the material in any and all electronic and digital formats and for use on the Internet Magazine web sites and any future medium for the full period of copyright therein and all renewals and extensions thereof and all rights of a like nature wherever subsisting. In the respect of Photography this includes all images shot during the commissioned assignment and if requested all images must be supplied."

The telegraphmediagroup have a similar clause as part of their terms and conditions:

"We and those authorised by us, shall have an irrevocable, assignable licence for the period of copyright in such work to use, and exercise all rights in, any such work in any publication or service and in any current or future media worldwide,"
 EMAP and EMAP active:

"By signing and returning this agreement to us, you irrevocably and unconditionally assign to us by way of present assignment of present and future copyright, the entire copyright in the commissioned works throughout the world (including any amendments and extensions to that copyright).  You waive an and all moral rights you have in the commissioned works."

Why is it that publications seek 'all rights' in this way? 


Clearly publishers recognise the value of the photographs supplied.  Under normal circumstances a staff photographer who is paid by a publisher to work for a magazine or newspaper, or publishing group, by virtue of being employed has the copyright of his work related material vested in the company. The company pays wages, holiday pay, sick pay, travel expense (usually a vehicle) supplies photographic kit (not inexpensive), and all the expenses incurred whilst undertaking assignments.  A freelance on the other hand gets paid a commission fee for the assignment, or when the work is submitted speculatively a fee for the use.  Usually subject to a minimum, and the larger the picture reproduction, better the position etc., the greater the fee.  A freelance commission is traditionally submitted on a 'first use' basis.

Some photographs have a greater value than simply this 'first use', and a photographer following a good business model will want to exploit such value in the form of secondary and subsequent sales. Clearly, not every photograph will sell in this way so it is a welcome extra for a photographer when such an opportunity occurs.

Occasionally, the publication will want to use a photograph a second time to illustrate a similar story on a later date, and it is almost always more cost effective to use a picture used before at a discounted rate than commission a photographer to cover the event, occasion or person again.

Photographs from a photographer's stock archive are usually less expensive to licence than commissioning a photographer to cover an event, and sometimes of course a particular instance is not repeated. Photographs of say the 'Cantona kick', or 'the first streaker at Wimbledon', have a value because of their rarity.

Sometimes the (unnecessary) requirement to acquire 'all rights' are down to the desire to sell on the photographs to third parties, and deliberately cut out the creator from any remuneration gained. Something traditionally the photographer has been able to do to boost his or her own income.

Others might put it down to corporate laziness (or greed) in that if one only has images in one's own photo-library that are licence free, then no one has to 'waste time' contacting photographers, or indeed paying for the extra often unconnected uses. Saves staff time and reproduction fees, and the only person to lose out is - the photographer.




If a multi-million pound business makes an extra couple of thousand pounds from a photographer becasue they don't pay subsequent reproduction rights, or because they syndicate a few sales, the advantage to that company is totally insignificant.  

For a photographer to lose those few thousand pounds can be a sizeable percentage of a year's profit, in many cases, twenty or even more percent. 

Does it sound fair?  

Is it right?

It is appalling when one sees businesses like publications, that are reliant on their content providers squeezing those suppliers, for every last drop, for no reasons other than they think they can, and it is a few more pennies to the shareholders.

All creators, whether they are writers, musicians, photographers, sculptors, painters are all easily exploited by the ruthless and the cynical. It makes sense in this increasingly business-led world for them to work together and support each other.  

How much worse is it when you see one creator exploit another for no reason other than greed?

Tuesday, 3 August 2010

Royal Photographic Society Put the Boot in to Professsional members




The Royal Photographic Society, that esteemed organisation basically aimed at amateur photographers has launched a new initiative which I am sure will be received with some trepidation by its professional members, especially those based in the South West who make at least some of their living documenting their region.
 
 
RPS is asking its members to give images to the South West Tourist Board.
 
Why? photographers are asking.  An exhibition perhaps, sponsored by the RPS.
 
Oh no. the reason is simple.
 
 
Our primary objective is to launch an advertising campaign based on the line "the season doesn’t end with summer". This will be online primarily, but hopefully tourism partners will commit to carrying this theme to a wider audience via:
* static displays at major motorway service areas,
* features in in-flight magazines,
* a media campaign taking in a range of national newspapers, specialist magazines and trade shows,
* static displays at major motorway service areas,
* features in in-flight magazines,
* a media campaign taking in a range of national newspapers, specialist magazines and trade shows,
 
That is to say, maximum exposure at minimum cost.  A cost that will largely be borne by the professional photographers who would normally be supplying images.  Now is that fair?  Is it ethical?
 
If it is good enough for the South West Tourist board, where else will the RPS turn its attentions?  The Olympics perhaps.
 
 
Someone stop this madness now

Tuesday, 18 May 2010

BBC Open the Copyright Battle

   Here we are at the start of a new Parliament, and we can be forgiven for thinking that all that nastiness with regard to our copyright and Clause 43 is long gone and behind us.  

But no, regrettably that is not the case.  The BBC, not an organisation to sit on its hands, is out of its corner and probing, already pitching for the next round of copyright attrition.

Copyright: time to change the laws? headlines the BBC website


Before I continue, I believe that  we all have to understand the difference between photographers, organisations such as the BBC, News International, and the end user or consumer, the reader and viewer.   All of us are links in this chain, in some cases, a photographer producing images will also be a consumer, not necessarily of his or her own images, but of other creator's work (images, music, or perhaps written material).

  1. Creators - These are the people who actually make the image, the music, write the books and articles. These are the people who (professionally) need paying for the time, effort and equipment that goes into making the works that we all consume.  The majority of these creators are either sole traders or small businesses, perhaps employing one or two assistants directly, and probably hiring, renting, consuming in the course of the production of their work.  However, not all creators are independent freelances, there are still a large number of creators who are employed and the work they create during the course of their employment belongs, or the intellectual copyright, currently belongs to their employer.  In these cases the creators have few if any rights at all.  All of the works created by these creators, freelance or employed, are covered by the current law which protects copyright for the lifetime of the creator and for seventy years after their death.
  2. The Users, Exploiters, Manipulators, Dealers, such as the BBC, News International, GNM - These are the (mostly) large corporations, companies and businesses that deal in imagery, in most cases to enhance their own products, or who put together collected created works and sell them on.  Whilst these exploiters do frequently create their own works through the employment of creators, more and more of the actual creating is left to freelance individuals and small companies.
  3. The Consumer - who is arguably the most important part of the chain, as without the consumer there would be no professional reason for a creator to create, nor a reason for the 'Users' to use.  The consumer buys the product, surfs the Internet, reads the book etc.
  4.  
    So why does the BBC want to change the laws around copyright so much?  For creators it is simple, we want to enforce the existing laws and beef them up a little. How many people, consumers and creators realise that (in the case of photographers), we have to assert the right to be recognised as the authors/creators of our own work?  This should be a simple human right.  Why should we have to insist on a credit alongside our images?  Just look at the site and piece I am referring too, and note that although the 'Stuart Franklin' picture has been credited to his agency Magnum, there is no mention of the photographer of the second image of the 'Globe Theatre'. (This incidentally is now an orphan!)  Stuart should also have been personally  credited for his iconic image not just in the text.

    How many people know that even if we do 'assert our rights to be recognised as the authors of our work', that in the case of newspapers, magazines and many books, the publisher is under no obligation to recognise these rights.  UK newspapers and magazines publish - deliberately - thousands of orphan images every week.  And because their work is not acknowledged, how many photographers find that they simply do not get paid by publishers who have used work kept on file, and just sit back and wait for the photograpaher to send an invoice?  No publisher should ever be just allowed to publish a creator's work without the express permission of that creator and without proactively paying for the right to do so.

    How many users and consumers realise that organisations such as the BBC, (totally against the spirit of all the copyright legislation we have) routinely insist on stripping the creator of all rights that they have - moral rights and commercial rights, on the 'give us everything or we won't use you' stick (not carrot and stick, just stick and stick).  It might be more palatable for the humble creator if the BBC and other large media corporations were to pay extra for the privilege of obtaining all these extra (and commercially lucrative) rights, but they don't, fees have remained static for over a decade, (whilst costs have more than doubled, let alone taking into account inflation).



     All of us are affected in the current recession and as a result of the banking crisis and ongoing cut-backs, and need to save.  As budgets are cut by the large users, smaller operations find themselves losing work and clients, or at the least those same clients with the lower budgets, insisting on more productivity for, (usually), less remuneration.  In a cut-throat business, where there is a lot of competition, and ironically, a shrinking market despite the huge expansion created via the Internet, creators can't cut their costs any further.

    The BBC for instance has started a shift from wholly owned content to taking content from freelances and small companies.  This has an immediate benefit for the Beeb in that employers costs are slashed in one easily achieved stroke.  But this creates a new dilemma for the exploiters, (particularly the BBC).  By using 'freelance' talent rather than 'employing' it, the overheads and costs are hugely reduced.  Bullying in the marketplace keeps the cost down of using those created works, it is often quoted quite correctly that the National Newspapers (for instance) have not increased their commission rates for photographers in sixteen years, (looking at my own receipts and talking to other photographers, suggests that this really is the case).  All this is good for the exploiter, so where is the dilemma you ask?  

    The costs have been reduced, freelances are kept on a low fee, but what about exploitation of that work?  Newspapers and the BBC want to be able to use that content across multiple platforms.  Wholly owned content can be used freely, legally freelance content can't. Newspapers are producing websites, and the BBC publishes books, magazines and websites; for these big corporations it is tiresome to have to pay content providers each time they want to reuse content.  They want to save manpower and cost by simply being licensed to use the material as often and in whatever manner they wish.  This should be good for the creators as more licenses should mean more pay.  But no, that is not how the users want the system to work.  They want everything. The easiest way for them to do this is to trample all over the rights of the creator and just insist on 'give us everything' and demand a complete rights transfer.  Totally against the spirit of the 1988 Copyright Designs and Patent Act, the Berne Convention and the WIPO Copyright Treaty

    This is the extract from the BBC Freelance Contract
    17. Intellectual Property Rights
    1. In consideration of the payment of the Fee, the Freelance hereby assigns and otherwise agrees to assign to the BBC absolutely and with full title guarantee, and warrants that any individual, agent or sub-contractor engaged by the Freelance to assist in providing the Product(s) and/or Services have assigned and/or agreed to assign to the Freelance absolutely and with full title guarantee all IPRs (both existing at the date hereof and in the future) in any Product(s) in all languages throughout the Universe for the full period of such rights (including all rights to renewals and extensions thereof).
    2. The Freelance hereby to the extent permissible by law, waives irrevocably and warrants that any individual, agent or sub-contractor engaged by the Freelance to assist in providing the Product(s) and/or Services have to the extent permissible by law waived irrevocably the benefits of any provision of law known as “moral rights” (including without limitation any right of the Freelance, the individual, agent or sub-contractor under sections 77 to 85 inclusive of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 and under any resale right arising from EU law) or any similar laws of any jurisdiction in which waiver is permissible.
    3. The Freelance hereby grants the BBC a non-exclusive, royalty free, irrevocable licence to use and sublicence any IPRs in any Product(s) under the Contract which have not, for whatsoever reasons, been assigned under this Clause 17.
    4. The Freelance hereby warrants that there are no potential, threatened or actual claims by its agents or subcontractors in respect of patents or potential patents.

    Copyright law is being trashed by the large corporations at the direct expense of the creator.  The BBC will only use photographers if they voluntarily give up their copyright, and then they exploit those rights to the nth degree.  Many will see this as nothing more than economic bullying.  It might also be seen as outright exploitation.  Yes, the creator 'technically' has a choice, but  'give us your images on our terms or we won't use you ever again', in a diminishing marketplace becomes a very difficult choice.
    Diminishing marketplace?  How can that be?  There are more images used now than every before in history.  The Internet alone uses uncountable numbers of new images every day.  But with Publishers and corporations employing fewer staff to create, there are more freelances out there.  And with colleges and universities churning out more students every year onto the marketplace, than there are places for them in industry, (more it is said than there are places in the industry). And combine that with the perceived ease of access to digital imagery, (every owner of a digital camera, seems to think that this enables the user to produce the imagery of the thirty year professional), we can perhaps begin to see where some of the problems lie.

    Publishers are keen to exploit today's marketplace, and are currently doing so against the spirit of international copyright.  The next step, and this is what we are currently seeing is an attempt to change the law so that what at the moment is merely immoral and reprehensible, becomes legally acceptable.

    It isn't just the BBC, much in the Public Eye recently has been the Guardians Rights Grab as outlined in their called 'Freelance Charter'.

    We accept your contribution on the basis that you agree to the terms set out below ("the licence") and grant us irrevocably and unconditionally the following rights to use, publish, transmit or license your contribution throughout the world for the full period of copyright in your contribution including all renewals, reversions, extensions and revivals of such period.

    They don't demand 'Copyright', but they demand the right to behave as if they have!!

    Going back to the BBC piece:

    "The issue of copyright has to strike a delicate balance between protecting the creators of music, words, or photographs and the dissemination of such material to a wider public. On the one hand, you want to ensure that the creators get paid for what they create. On the other, if copyright protection is too tight then dissemination of material becomes too restricted."

    This sounds very reasonable doesn't it?  Well it does until you actually look at what is being said and who says it, and what the actual facts of the situation are.

    I would start off by questioning this 'delicate balance' idea.  It isn't that delicate at all. It is quite simple.  An artist creates a work.  He or she then licenses that work, usually through a middleman, whether it be a recording company, the BBC or a large publishing corporation.  The work is then licensed to be distributed or used through that facilitator.  The license will outline the terms of distribution or use, and the return that the artist may expect.  Nothing difficult about that surely.

    The keys words here are "the dissemination of such material to a wider public" which is controlled by our large corporation.  That corporation can easily work within the terms of the contract between it and the creator. A clearly defined agreement tells the user what rights it has and also protects the creator.  It is in the interests of the user of the created work to smudge the definition of copyright, because that can mean greater exploitation for less outlay, something that currently many of the larger corporations appear to be doing by economic force.

    This in itself doesn't affect the consumer, who is usually totally unaware of the battles going on between creator and the middlemen.  The only loser is the creator.  The loosening of the Copyright laws will only be at the expense of the creator, the party already under the greatest pressure.  There is no advantage to the creator at all, in fact exactly the opposite. The net gain will be by the middlemen, not the consumer, and at a direct cost to the creator.

    Copyright has remained largely unchanged since 1988. The users and middlemen have certainly suffered no loss or restriction and none have yet outlined such loss.  Nor have consumers suffered.  That publishers choose to put so much more content on the Internet on a basically free of charge basis has been a direct benefit to the casual consumer. The problem for the creator is that the publisher wants to pay little or nothing for that free content and wishes it to be made available by the creator for free, and often at the cost of the conventional publication that it may well replace.

    Stuart Franklin when talking about images is quoted as saying:

     "We know exactly who is drawing photographs off our web site, we know who is downloading them and who has access to them."

    Which suggests that he is talking about all images copied from the Magnum website, but actually what he is referring to , if you listen to the initial interview (BBC Iplayer so it may not be there for long), are clients registered on their site and legitimately downloading images, and indeed in the original interview it certainly sounded to me like he said downloaded, rather than 'drawn', which in any case would be a strange word for a photographer to use when referring to websites.  

    As it stands at the moment, it is very difficult indeed to log who copies an image from my own website or any other for that matter.  What can be done however is use software programs to trace images used elsewhere on the web that might belong to one.  Large organisations such as Getty use Picscout, and recoup the not inconsequential cost by suing copyright infringers.


    The reference to 'if Shakespeare's works were still in copyright' seem pointless.  As he died over 400 years ago his work is well out of copyright and therefore in the public domain.  If he were alive today, he would be taking advantage of his undoubted talent and exploiting his works commercially, hopefully being dealt with fairly and not having publishers demand all rights to his work - which would indeed be a travesty!

    Olivier Laurent's comments are interesting, but it is unclear to what he is referring to from the quotes extracted here, and indeed listening to the original broadcast doesn't help us much either.  What industry is he referring to  exactly? 

    Presumably it can't be creators as such because we have no control of the web.  His comment: 

    "Twenty years ago you cut pictures out of a paper and put them on your wall - that would be stealing as well," 

    Is not strictly speaking factually correct either.  He might have a point if the cutting were exhibited in a public place as artwork, but it would not be against any law I am aware of to display a cutting on a wall in your own home for example.

    William Fisher at Harvard University thinks copyright protection is too strict does he.  Well he would wouldn't he, he wants to be able to copy other peoples work and enable them to be incorporated into new mashed up work.  Why should this not be done be asking permission first?

    "There needs to be more creative freedom," he believes.  Freedom to use other peoples work that is...

     He goes on:

    "The current system is over-protective. It extends copyright protection to too every snapshot, every digital image - billions are being created every minute all around the world and they are all protected by copyright law. ... too much copyright protection impedes cultural conversations and cultural usage"


    He continues:

    "It would be better if the photographer registered any image be wanted to protect with an online registration system," he says, "and that any other work was in the public domain."
     

    This would then mean that any image published on a personal web site on Facebook, on Flickr where the creator was not a professional and had not automatically registered his or her work could be used, by anyone, for any purpose, anywhere.

    Amateurs sharing their work with their friends could not do so unless they were willing to risk it being hijacked, not just by some student copying the work to use say in a new painting or artwork, but the BBC or News International copying it and popping it into their own picture libraries for use as needed.  And of course no copyright protection, means no moral rights, and no credits, and absolutely no control over where, or by whom, these images could be used. (Not just the BBC, but what about the big oil companies, tobacco companies or the BNP and other political parties?)

    People like William Fisher clearly mean well, but they simply to do not seem to think through these simplistic proposals, or the possible consequences of what they suggest.

    But the BBC? I bet they simply love William Fisher, simplistic proposals and all...