Showing posts with label Photographers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Photographers. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 June 2015

Creators working together?


I have been reading with great interest the open letter sent by Taylor Swift to Apple in response to their very generous offer of giving away other peoples work for free (musicians work that is), and how Apple have done a very sensible about turn in the face of mass public pressure (no one wants to look bad in front of their customer base)  To Apple Love Taylor

 
Even greater interest for me was the second open letter written by my friend Jason Sheldon, a successful and skilled concert Photographer, in which he publishes the 'Concert Photo Authorisation form' that all photographers have to sign before they can photograph Ms Taylor in action for their publications.

Ms Taylor's contract demands access to all the photographers concert photos for free, not just for three months as Apple had intended with Ms Taylor's work.








Of course to music and concert photographers this kind of rights grab will not be a novelty. I have a personal collection of scores of these unfair contracts. Some go as far as to demand ownership of work done, and even to demand that the photographer then indemnify the band group for any losses they incur,  and most insist on ownership (copyright) of the photographs for the band to do with as they will - all of course at the expense of the photographer who is not allowed to use or licence the images he or she has worked so hard to get.


As a result of these 'sign and give away your work and rights' or 'don't sign and don't take photograph' contracts I have largely pulled out of  concert photography.  Too many times, I have arrived at the venue, sometimes after travelling several hours to be presented with a contract that has to be signed at the door of the venue minutes before the performance commences.   Not even the common decency to send out the contract when the access has been confirmed by e-mail. Clearly, those issuing these contracts know they are unfair, so they issue them only when the photographer is under the most pressure - as they are about to go into the gig. No chance to get them vetted legally etc.





Interestingly enough the Independent followed up Sheldon's piece with a response from Taylor Swifts 'people'. In the piece:

"Swift's UK spokesperson has now responded with the following statement: "The standard photography agreement has been misrepresented in that it clearly states that any photographer shooting 'The 1989 World Tour' has the opportunity for further use of said photographs with management's approval."

Ok, yes it does, but I wonder how easy or difficult that permission would be to get? From Firefly? Swifts management team, I wonder how many photographers have received such permission easily and quickly without any kind of hassle?

It goes on:

""Another distinct misrepresentation is the claim that the copyright of the photographs will be with anyone other than the photographer - this agreement does not transfer copyright away from the photographer."

Actually there was no such misrepresentation, What Sheldon actually says is:

" it appears to be a complete rights grab"

 And that it is; and it goes on and demands that you are granted free and unlimited use of our work, worldwide, in perpetuity..  Now that isn't a transfer of copyright, but no one ever said it was. Perhaps Taylor's UK representative simply does not understand copyright?

She could revise it here Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988

Of course swifts UK representative total omits to deal with the fact that the agreement  demands that you are granted free and unlimited use of our work, worldwide, in perpetuity. And Swift wasn't happy  (quite rightly) with Apple taking only three months!!!

 But we are told the agreement has been updated. Yes, yes it has. If anything it is even worse...




 I would draw your attention dear reader to paragraph 3:

"On behalf of yourself and the Publication, you expressly grant FEI, and its related entities, including, but not limited to 13 Management, LLC; Taylor Nation, LLC; and Taylor Swift Productions, Inc. (the “Related Entities”), the perpetual, worldwide right to use the published Photographs for any non-commercial purpose (in all media and formats), including but not limited to publicity and promotion on their web sites and/or social media accounts or pages."

 There it is again free use for ever and a day, and this includes publicity and promotion (generally regarded in the industry as Commercial use by the way)


And Paragraph 5 is good too:

"If you fail to fully comply with this Authorization, authorized agents of FEI, the Artist or the Related Entities may confiscate and/or destroy the technology or devices that contain the master files of the Photographs and other images, including, but not limited to, cell phones and memory cards, and the Photographs and any other images; and eject you from the venue, in addition to any other remedy available to FEI, Artist and/or the Subjects. You and the Publication jointly and severally shall indemnify and hold FEI, the Artist, the Related Entities and the Subjects harmless from and against any and all claims, losses, injury,
damage, and expenses incurred by any or all of them arising out of this Authorization and/or the undersigned’s attendance at the Concert. You and the Publication hereby release FEI, Artist, the Related Entities, their officers, directors, employers, contractors, and agents, and the Subjects from and against any and all liability arising out of this authorization and/or your attendance at the Concert"


They give themselves permission to confiscate or destroy?  Even the police are not allowed to do that!!

This has to be one of the worst band agreements I have ever seen. Compare it to the reasonable one I refer to later in this blog.

Taylor Swifts Management Company Firefly are not the only ones who try and restrict Photographers to a point where covering the band is simply uneconomic. The well known and popular singer Kylie Minogue's management company Darenote Limited go a step further and demand that the photographer assign copyright. (see note 2.)



"We shall own and you hereby assign to us the copyright in and to the Photographs"


As if it makes it all OK then say  (note 3):

"We shall not exploit the photographs in any manner without your consent"

(By this they mean they can use the images for their own use, but will not in anyway sell them on or licence them to third parties)

But then confusingly go onto say (note 4) 

"We shall be entitled to assign transfer sub-license mortgage charge or otherwise dispose of our rights hereunder to any person or entity without reference to you."

Wow.  Now that is a real rights grab!!!


What has probably not been made clear to the reader so far; indeed I don't believe it has been mentioned in any discussion of band-photographer contracts, is that the photographer does not get these 'contact or agreements' in advance of the show. No! In every circumstance I have experienced, and in every circumstance that fellow photographers tell me of, these contracts are handed to the photographer as they are about to enter the venue, and always on a 'sign or you don't get to photograph' basis.  If the photographer queries the legality of the document - we all do, then of course there is no way of discussing or negotiating a change as the venue staff have no control or jurisdiction. The answer is always:

"We have been told sign or no photographs!"

Does that sound right? 
Does it sound fair?  
Does it come across as a legitimate way to do business?

If a photographer is employed, then he or she is being asked to sign a legal document that in all probability they have no authorisation to sign, and without the publications legal department having the option to look at it. Also without the option of discussion.

If, as most are, the photographer is either a sole trader, or a self employed person asked to attend the concert by a publication, then the situation is worse. Not only do they not have the authorisation to sign on behalf of a publication, but inevitably they are dependent on selling the photos to their client in order to earn that day.  Travelling seventy miles to a gig, and then being presented with a legal looking document that you can't possibly sign is not good for your average freelance.  If they do decide to sign and cover the gig then there is only the one reproduction fee from the initial client - the photographer then has no control of their clients (or their own) future use of their own created work.

Or worse still, the photographer doesn't sign, doesn't get paid, and can't even recover the expenses (mileage etc).



Fortunately, such restrictive contracts or agreements are still comparatively rare, and only a small percentage of bands issue them. But that percentage is increasing!


Bands are keen to protect the commercial exploitation of their image - marketing t-shirts, gifts, memorabilia and suchlike, and they have every right to do so. 

Photographers and bands/musicians should work together in this. 
No images = nothing to exploit of course. 
But it should be working together not one party cynically exploiting the other - as Apple initially intended.

  So what would a reasonable agreement look like you want to know?  I am glad you asked because I happen to have one here...



Nothing here to make anyone's eyes water. Protects the artist - ensures that the editorial photographer does not sell on photographs to competing commercial concerns etc, and protects the photographer too, by ensuring that there aren't any of those nasty rights grabs, demands for free pictures or control of reproduction.



What about outside music?


As many photographers will be able to tell you, unfair contracts are not limited to bands and music.

Editorial photographers all over the UK, (actually the world), are getting clobbered by unfair work conditions in the form of over zealous contracts, and inevitably they are presented as - 'sign or don't work'.

When Johnston Press made so many of its staff photographers redundant, and offered to take some of them back on as freelance workers, there seemed to be little in it for the photographers. They lost the security of their paid job, company vehicle, company equipment, paid holidays, sick pay and simply found themselves being asked to do the same job for less money, a lot more expense, and they were still expected to sign away they rights to their own work!


     "You irrevocably waive any rights that you have or may in future be entitled to under the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 and any other moral rights to which you may be entitled under any legislation now existing or in future enacted in any part of the world, in respect of the work provided by you"



Barcroft Media (an international media content company based in London, England.) made this part of an agreement with contributing photographers:


"Photographer agrees to work for Barcroft as an independent contractor, providing photography-related services upon assignment from Barcroft.   Photographer agrees to transfer all photographs to Barcroft immediately upon completion of an assignment. Photographer further agrees not to sell any image taken during the contracted event to any other person or business without Barcroft’s express written permission."  
and


"All of Photographer’s work while on assignment for Barcroft will be considered work-for-hire under the United States Copyright Act of 1976.  All photographs and images, inclusive of electronic files and other materials related to them, are the property of Barcroft."

Work for Hire is of course a US phenomenon, and under UK law the photographer is still regarded as a freelance and therefore retains copyright. To demand copyright in this aggressive manner is totally counter to the spirit and legality of the UK's Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988


 A National Magazines contract also has a rights grab as one of its main clauses:

"ALL RIGHTS" means National Magazine acquires the entire worldwide copyright in the material and all other intellectual property rights in the material for all uses including but not limited to all rights to use the material in any and all electronic and digital formats and for use on the Internet Magazine web sites and any future medium for the full period of copyright therein and all renewals and extensions thereof and all rights of a like nature wherever subsisting. In the respect of Photography this includes all images shot during the commissioned assignment and if requested all images must be supplied."

The telegraphmediagroup have a similar clause as part of their terms and conditions:

"We and those authorised by us, shall have an irrevocable, assignable licence for the period of copyright in such work to use, and exercise all rights in, any such work in any publication or service and in any current or future media worldwide,"
 EMAP and EMAP active:

"By signing and returning this agreement to us, you irrevocably and unconditionally assign to us by way of present assignment of present and future copyright, the entire copyright in the commissioned works throughout the world (including any amendments and extensions to that copyright).  You waive an and all moral rights you have in the commissioned works."

Why is it that publications seek 'all rights' in this way? 


Clearly publishers recognise the value of the photographs supplied.  Under normal circumstances a staff photographer who is paid by a publisher to work for a magazine or newspaper, or publishing group, by virtue of being employed has the copyright of his work related material vested in the company. The company pays wages, holiday pay, sick pay, travel expense (usually a vehicle) supplies photographic kit (not inexpensive), and all the expenses incurred whilst undertaking assignments.  A freelance on the other hand gets paid a commission fee for the assignment, or when the work is submitted speculatively a fee for the use.  Usually subject to a minimum, and the larger the picture reproduction, better the position etc., the greater the fee.  A freelance commission is traditionally submitted on a 'first use' basis.

Some photographs have a greater value than simply this 'first use', and a photographer following a good business model will want to exploit such value in the form of secondary and subsequent sales. Clearly, not every photograph will sell in this way so it is a welcome extra for a photographer when such an opportunity occurs.

Occasionally, the publication will want to use a photograph a second time to illustrate a similar story on a later date, and it is almost always more cost effective to use a picture used before at a discounted rate than commission a photographer to cover the event, occasion or person again.

Photographs from a photographer's stock archive are usually less expensive to licence than commissioning a photographer to cover an event, and sometimes of course a particular instance is not repeated. Photographs of say the 'Cantona kick', or 'the first streaker at Wimbledon', have a value because of their rarity.

Sometimes the (unnecessary) requirement to acquire 'all rights' are down to the desire to sell on the photographs to third parties, and deliberately cut out the creator from any remuneration gained. Something traditionally the photographer has been able to do to boost his or her own income.

Others might put it down to corporate laziness (or greed) in that if one only has images in one's own photo-library that are licence free, then no one has to 'waste time' contacting photographers, or indeed paying for the extra often unconnected uses. Saves staff time and reproduction fees, and the only person to lose out is - the photographer.




If a multi-million pound business makes an extra couple of thousand pounds from a photographer becasue they don't pay subsequent reproduction rights, or because they syndicate a few sales, the advantage to that company is totally insignificant.  

For a photographer to lose those few thousand pounds can be a sizeable percentage of a year's profit, in many cases, twenty or even more percent. 

Does it sound fair?  

Is it right?

It is appalling when one sees businesses like publications, that are reliant on their content providers squeezing those suppliers, for every last drop, for no reasons other than they think they can, and it is a few more pennies to the shareholders.

All creators, whether they are writers, musicians, photographers, sculptors, painters are all easily exploited by the ruthless and the cynical. It makes sense in this increasingly business-led world for them to work together and support each other.  

How much worse is it when you see one creator exploit another for no reason other than greed?

Tuesday, 3 August 2010

Royal Photographic Society Put the Boot in to Professsional members




The Royal Photographic Society, that esteemed organisation basically aimed at amateur photographers has launched a new initiative which I am sure will be received with some trepidation by its professional members, especially those based in the South West who make at least some of their living documenting their region.
 
 
RPS is asking its members to give images to the South West Tourist Board.
 
Why? photographers are asking.  An exhibition perhaps, sponsored by the RPS.
 
Oh no. the reason is simple.
 
 
Our primary objective is to launch an advertising campaign based on the line "the season doesn’t end with summer". This will be online primarily, but hopefully tourism partners will commit to carrying this theme to a wider audience via:
* static displays at major motorway service areas,
* features in in-flight magazines,
* a media campaign taking in a range of national newspapers, specialist magazines and trade shows,
* static displays at major motorway service areas,
* features in in-flight magazines,
* a media campaign taking in a range of national newspapers, specialist magazines and trade shows,
 
That is to say, maximum exposure at minimum cost.  A cost that will largely be borne by the professional photographers who would normally be supplying images.  Now is that fair?  Is it ethical?
 
If it is good enough for the South West Tourist board, where else will the RPS turn its attentions?  The Olympics perhaps.
 
 
Someone stop this madness now

Monday, 14 June 2010

I can't work for national newspapers, but I'm a photojournalist; I need someone to publish my work.



 A colleague asked me today, what he should be doing with a lifetime of acquired skills as a photographer  working for newspapers, when newspapers were down sizing, losing staff and cutting budgets to freelances?

What answers could I give to this question, especially as we have just learned that the Mirror Group is following the Guardian, News International and others in losing photographic contributors.


A few years ago after spending all my working life supplying newspapers as a freelance I had to make the decision to carry on regardless, supplying regular newspaper clients for the same money each year, whilst my expenses increased, and in the case of regional newspapers actually for less money than a few years before, or to say enough is enough.

My business model of supplying mostly national newspapers was no longer viable.

Whilst the actual catalyst of change for me was the death of my business partner, it was clear that had that not happened the business would either have slowly expired, or maybe, if I had been lucky my little agency might have been bought out by Getty or one of the others.

The change was difficult, painful, and hard.

I left sport - my comfort zone for more than 25 years, and London where I had been based.  I ended up going part-time for two years – in Nottingham.

When I came back to full-time smudging it was not as a smudger, but as a photographer supplying editorial imagery to businesses, non government organisations, and the local authority.  I also do a hell of a lot of stock.  

From 2003 - 2009 my business improved year on year, quarter on quarter, although the overheads are somewhat scary compared to say 1994 - (the last year I experienced a proper increase in pay from a newspaper).

This last 18 months have been very difficult, and my gross has remained static.  I have had to continue re-inventing myself, my work and finding new clients all this time, and am doing so today.  It is not easy; there is no magic spell.  Many of us (photographers) will not make it through to retirement as full-time photographers; that is clear.  Statistically I suspect those of us who have been in the industry longest will have the best chance of weathering the difficulties.

The one thing I am certain of, however we survive, and to whoever we manage to sell our work, few of us will find that newspapers form a majority of our clientele going forward. The Guardian, The Telegraph, News International, Manchester Evening News, Liverpool Post, and now Mirror Group Newspapers all have either dispensed with staff photographers or cut back to no more than a handful.

Freelancers whilst used in droves twenty years ago, are now hardly budgeted for.  We have to get real, and have to understand, that whilst we may be photojournalists by trade, training and profession, we simply aren't going to be supplying newspapers going forward.

I spoke at length to one of the local universities here in Nottingham a few weeks ago, and virtually none of those who get degrees go into the photographic industry, and none of them become photojournalists, (can't imagine what they do with all those Photography degrees).


"Where do I go now?" My friend asked.



Newspapers are not the only outlets for editorial photography.

In the last fortnight, I have photographed a garden centre and an Aikido Dojo for web sites and promo literature.  I have supplied a German photo agency with hundreds of stock images, I have supplied imagery to the local council for their brochures, edited hundreds of images for UK based photo agencies, supplied images to several unions for web use and staff magazines, copied a 1950s photo album and made it into a photo book, resurrected several 'turn of the century' photographs, and reprinted them for private use.

All of these things have utilised my skills as a digital editorial photographer, none of these clients is a newspaper.

Nobody said it would be easy.




Pete Jenkins
www.petejenkins.co.uk
www.onlinepictureproof.com/petejenkins
www.photographerspro.eu/pete_jenkins/

Member of: The National Union of Journalists

Wednesday, 18 November 2009

© the way ahead: A Copyright Strategy for the Digital Age



For some time now we have been waiting for the Government to ‘announce’ its strategy with regard to copyright and orphan works. There has been much debate about the efforts in the United States to introduce an Orphan Works bill, and huge concern about the knock on effect of such a bill to ordinary creators such as independent freelance photographers (both editorial like myself and otherwise). I last talked about this in my blog in January (29th Jan 2009), and with the Queens speech due this afternoon it is time to revisit the subject.

The Gowers review was published a while ago now


Then, we had the Copyright Consultation document from David Lammy. I responded to this myself as did many others, and I also took part in an online debate held by the British Journal of Photography along with Paul Brown, the managing director of the Mary Evans Picture Library and chairman of the British Association of Picture Libraries and Agencies, BAPLA's executive director, Simon Cliffe, John Toner, freelance organiser at the National Union of Journalists, and Rupert Grey, consultant in the Litigation Group at media law specialist Swan Turton Solicitors

and after this in June the Digital Britain report.



The latest document“© the way ahead, A strategy for copyright in the digital age”, was published on 28th October, and it is this document that I want to start looking at.

It is a long document so I am going to take it in sections, looking first at the summary and Introduction.

© the way ahead
Initial Response by Pete Jenkins

Please note , the 'Indented' paragraphs in italics are quotes from the document.

David Lammy says:

We are, however, at a crossroads in our relationship with our new digital world.
Digital technology means access to information on a vast scale. It has changed the way people publish and consume works. It allows anyone and everyone to make and distribute quick, cheap, and totally accurate copies. Consumers have reached out to grab the potential of this new technology. The copyright debate, once in the hands of the professionals of the creative industries, is now a debate for everyone. Businesses and governments have seen the challenges but have been slow to respond.

Although creative industries and governments are trying to catch up with the digital world, there is more to be done. We must push harder. Policy makers need to get ahead of the game. They need to recognise the need to work with an awareness of what consumers are doing and want to do. And they need to recognise that no single national government has control of the agenda.

We must now work within the international and European framework to ensure copyright keeps up with technology and consumer behaviour. We have to make it simpler, and make it address the concerns of all those who have an interest in the copyright system: business, consumers, creators, and copyright owners.

(c) the way ahead: A Copyright Strategy for the Digital Age is a recognition that the world we live in has changed. This report is the latest part of our ongoing response.


Page 1 – Executive Summary.

Findings from the Copyright Strategy

For the first time, individual citizens have the means to create, use and distribute copyright works through digital technology. People want to make use of these opportunities but in doing so it is almost inevitable that they will violate copyright. This mismatch of expectations is significant because neither the law nor people’s attitudes is easy to change.

Copyright is also complex for users. Much of this complexity can be addressed by rights holders and how they administer their rights. This would have many advantages over changes to the law, which can be slow and risks adding to rather than reducing complexity.

Making non-commercial use less onerous for consumers, for example by removing the need to seek permission and make payment for personal use of individual copyright works, would help tackle the “mismatch of expectations” problem. But fair compensation for rights holders would be required. Action at a European level would be necessary.

Processes for licensing copyright works need to be improved. The Government has already brought forward proposals in the Digital Britain Report, which noted problems with access to “orphan works” and the potential benefits of extended collective licensing in tackling some of these problems. Non-compulsory registration systems may also help rights holders manage their rights more effectively.

Creative industries face real challenges in monetising content. Firms must continue to evolve products and services to offer consumers something they value at prices they are prepared to pay. Education and enforcement can support these efforts but cannot tackle infringement of copyright on their own.


Pete Jenkins response:

It is positive to see that we all understand that everyone is or has the potential to be a creator. More so now than ever before. Whilst the public as well as specialist creators have always had access to pen and paper and have been able to create works, whether they be written or illustrative, the digital age whilst not actually making access any easier (what can be easier than a pen) has made the publication of such works more accessible to everyone who wants to take advantage of it. However, as has been said many times before, the mere ownership of as pen does not make one a prize winning author. The mere act of publishing itself does not convey any kind of quality on what has been published.

There is a big difference between copying some one else’s created works and publishing something that has been worked on and crafted onesself. Just because it is easier to copy and paste, does not mean that one automatically has the right to do so.

Ease of access is a wonderful thing, but this should not mean that publishing on the web or elsewhere justifies any kind of anarchy.

Many, (not all), citizens make an assumption that because something has been published that it is automatically in the public domain, and that therefore it can copied and published further at will. There is also the thought that because something has been published on the web site of a large faceless publishing company that further copying is not hurting anyone, and that in any case such theft is somehow justified because of the size and wealth of large faceless corporations.

What is not understood here, is that most creations, unlike say a packet of cornflakes in a supermarket, are most likely the product of one persons labor and creative process, and not necessarily part of a faceless corporation conveyor belt.

Many, (if not most), Creators make a living by selling licenses to reproduce their product. It has to be a license rather than outright sale, as outright sale to just one party would deny the rest of the population access to that work. A scheme of licensing means, (or should mean), that the creator retains ultimate control of his or her, created work. This is important to insure that the work is not used inappropriately, as well as ensuring a small income stream for the creator.

Contrary to the general perception of the population, creators are almost exclusively on a low wage, and do not make a lot of money out of their skills, indeed, as has been said many times before, freelance editorial newspaper photographers for instance are paid the same today in 2009 (or less), than the received for the same work in 1994. This is not healthy for creators, and casts a shadow over the commitment of those publishing organisations that pay these fees.

It has been said many times in this document that copyright is complex. Exactly how is it complex? One either has obtained permission to use a work or one hasn’t. How is this complex? How is obtaining a license to use an image any different to obtaining the hire of a car. Indeed, observers might say that in this respect copyright is a far simpler process, yet there is no general outcry over either the cost or the process of car hire.

Photographers are very concerned by the idea of,

Making non-commercial use less onerous for consumers, for example by removing the need to seek permission and make payment for personal use of individual copyright works, would help tackle the “mismatch of expectations” problem.


Why is it so important for consumers to have a right over created works that they have made no contribution to the production of? And how can this be deemed fair? Why is there a requirement to remove the need to seek permission? Is this not a basic moral courtesy in our society? And does not removing the need to seek permission, re-enforce the falsely held belief that individuals can do what ever they want with someone else’s created works, regardless of context and intent?

The mismatch of expectations problems so described come from a lack of education. Society has had handed to it this wonderful publishing access opportunity (digital publishing and the ‘world wide web’), but has had little or no education in how such an opportunity can be correctly used, and the rights and wrongs of publishing this or that work.

Reading, writing and arithmetic are the core subjects in this country’s educational system, understandably one of the envies of the rest of the world, it would seem simple common sense in the 21st century to include in the core curriculum, copyright and publishing. If we taught our children and our society how to publish correctly, not just how to use a keyboard and access the ‘world wide web’, many of these confusions and misconceptions would no longer exist.

It is unclear to me as a professional photographer of more than thirty years experience, and indeed to other creators, when the matter is discussed in professional forums etc, what is wrong with the current process for licensing copyright works. One who wishes to publish seeks permission from the one who holds the rights. What can be simpler than that?

Creators are aware that users of imagery such as large publishing companies wish to simplify the process, by saying (say) that one small payment to a licnece holder should then entitle the publisher to publish that work wherever and whenever that publisher chooses . But this can be identified an attempt to get work cheaper and exploit the creator, rather than simplifying any publishing process as such. One must be careful not to confuse corporate greed disguised by a wish to simplify this or that process. Any attempt to simplify a process which actually work very well in it self should be made very carefully and not just be driven by the greed of those who want creators work cheaper or free, and that goes as much of large corporations as it does for individual members of the public.

Access to ‘orphan works’, as they have been described in this document, are of huge concern to individual creators.

If one doesn’t know a child’s name is the child therefore an orphan? Of course not. The same goes with a created work. There are so many situations where, especially publications authors details can be separated from a created work that alarm bells ring very loudly for any creator and supplier of work to publishers.

  • In the past contact details would be attached to the back of hard copy images via a piece of paper glued in one corner. If that paper became removed, did the work become an orphan? Of course not.
  • Later when images were scanned, contact details would be added in an extended canvass field below the actual image itself. But in the reproduction process this canvass addition to the visible image was cropped out, and often the image would be resaved without the caption field leaving the saved image unidentified. Did this make the image and orphan? – NO.
  • In the age of fully digital imaging with photographs captured in a digital format photographers go to great effort to complete meta data panels within the digital data of the image. No image should therefore be an orphan. However, in many cases on uploading to the World Wide Web, storage in certain data-bases, all this electronic tagging data is removed. Do these images then become orphans? A ludicrous assertion.

Many of the so-called problems with orphans are caused by poor storage, poor handling and in some cases deliberate intent. The idea that a non-compulsory registration system might also help rights holders manage their rights more effectively, is tantamount to saying that it is all the rights holder’s responsibility. Rather than suggesting that rights holders should be put to more expense in time and financial cost that registration in systems that do not exist, creators would suggest that actually removing the contact details from digital files should be made illegal, and effectively enforced by law. No creator has the ability to stop 2nd and 3rd parties abusing images by removing copyright and creator metadata and details, but those who handle images can certainly exercise responsibility. This does not need any new system to be put in place, nor need it impose any cost on creators.

Whilst it is true that,

Firms must continue to evolve products and services to offer consumers something they value at prices they are prepared to pay. Education and enforcement can support these efforts but cannot tackle infringement of copyright on their own.


No creator who has given this any thought would expect ‘education and enforcement’ to be the answer to everything, but currently the balance of power is very much in favour of the abuser of creators rights. Education in copyright and the publishing and creation of works is pitiful, and lacking in most cases. There is a huge area of improvement possible here, and it would seem a simple matter to introduce it into the core curriculum. Indeed, one would have thought this essential in our digital age.

As for enforcement, this is currently regarded as a joke by most creators. Most individuals do not have the time, finance or legal skill to pursue copyright infringors in the courts, courts themselves who in many cases do not always understand the process involved. And even when cases are won, it is usual only possible to recover the amount that should have been paid in the first place, with no punative damages. Such a process actually encourages copyright theft rather than preventing it. Some larger organisations have recently had some success in pursuing copyright thieves, but they are able to afford processes and recovery agents that sole proprietors simply do not have access to at this time.


Actions and recommendations

Based on these findings, the Government’s intentions are:

  • for authors of copyright works; to support fair treatment through new model contracts and clauses and fair returns for use of their work by improving education about and enforcement of rights;
  • for rights holders; to help secure a viable future by encouraging the development of new business models, modernising the licensing process and maintaining support for education about and enforcement of rights;
  • for consumers; to allow them to benefit from the digital age by seeking to legitimise noncommercial use of legitimately-purchased copyright works and improving access to ‘orphan works’ such as out-of-print books;
  • for educators and researchers; to support them by improving access to works, resolving issues around copyright and contract and ensuring exceptions to copyright are right for the digital age; and
  • for businesses and other users; to work towards a simpler copyright system by, improving the copyright licensing process and encouraging the development of new business models.

This means:
  • UK action to improve access to orphan works, enable extended collective licensing, encourage the development of model contracts and clauses, and tackle P2P fi le-sharing; and
  • A willingness on the Government’s part to consider European action that provides commonsense rules for private, non-commercial use of copyright material that will give consumers much more freedom to do what they want (such as creating mash-ups) and make clear what they cannot do.


Pete Jenkins response:

There is no other obvious response to:

"for authors of copyright works; to support fair treatment through new model contracts and clauses and fair returns for use of their work by improving education about and enforcement of rights;"


other than to applaud the statement. This is exactly what creators want to hear. It will also be of huge value to the end user, and indeed, clarify matters for the agent or publisher. However, such good intentions need very careful monitoring.

The statement:

“to allow them to benefit from the digital age by seeking to legitimise noncommercial use of legitimately-purchased copyright works and improving access to ‘orphan works’ such as out-of-print books;”


would seem to require more than a little clarification. Especially with regard to ‘out-of-print’ books. The mere fact that a book is out of print does not make it an orphan, and indeed the very notion seems to distort the whole notion of orphan works. A three-hundred-year old book that is out of print, is a different matter to a book that is out of print for merely five years, and when the author is still alive and identified.

"for educators and researchers; to support them by improving access to works, resolving issues around copyright and contract and ensuring exceptions to copyright are right for the digital age;"


Educators and researchers should not be exempt from copyright legislation and laws. That they should be allowed ‘some’ access to material is not to be denied, but exemption from copyright laws is going to far. Any blanket exemption is tantamount to inviting abuse. It would certainly be innapropriate for educational organisations to obtain material under an educational exemption, and then use this very same material for commercial gain. Before any special cases are made for education, it would seem prudent to ensure that that same educational system is fully informed in copyright matters and education those in its charge – both pupils and teachers.

"for businesses and other users; to work towards a simpler copyright system by, improving the copyright licensing process and encouraging the development of new business models.”


Publishers and big businesses are continually trying to simplify the copyright system, by attempting to introduce rights grabbing contracts to the creators who supply their imagery, but these are not attempts to simplify any process, or to improve copyright licensing but are aimed solely at making imagery cheaper for the publisher at the direct expense of the creator. This sort of business skullduggery should be directly opposed by this legislation and should not be encouraged in any way shape or form.

This means:

  • UK action to improve access to orphan works, enable extended collective licensing, encourage the development of model contracts and clauses, and tackle P2P file-sharing; and
  • A willingness on the Government’s part to consider European action that provides commonsense rules for private, non-commercial use of copyright material that will give consumers much more freedom to do what they want (such as creating mash-ups) and make clear what they cannot do.



Pete Jenkins response:

Few creators perceive that there is currently a problem with ‘orphan works’, and even fewer believe that there is a need for copyright legislation to be evaded or avoided.

There is severe reservation amongst creators – editorial photographers in particular about ‘extended collective licensing’ being a method used for collecting payments for use of so-called orphan works. Just because a work has not got a clearly identified author immediately identifiable does not mean that the work is out of copyright, nor that an author is not identifiable with a little bit of effort. How exactly can collective licensing by its very definition a method of licensing for small amounts of uncollectable fees, be used to collect licensing fees? Orphan works simply do not fit into this remit of a collecting society. Creators want a proper fee for every use of their work, in the same way in that they wish to retain control over how their work is used. There are no ‘blanket fees’ for licensing created works, how could there be? Orphan works are totally different from photocopying licences – something which collecting societies work incredibly well in collecting on behalf of creators. How can collecting societies negotiate every individual license, which is what creators have to do, quite rightly so. Most editorial photographers simply do not see the connection between the two issues.

Model contracts and clauses for the licensing of created works do exist, and there does not seem to be a deficiency in this area.

“commonsense rules for private, non-commercial use of copyright material that will give consumers much more freedom to do what they want (such as creating mash-ups) and make clear what they cannot do.”


Again, is it in the best interest for creators to allow unlicensed use of their work, even for consumers? Consumers are after all the end-user. To give them free rein to use created works as they wish seems unfair to creators, and will likely cause even more copyright infringements.

Is not a ‘mash-up’ the use of two or more created works to produce a third hybrid work? Why is it deemed innapropriate for the original creators to be asked if they give permission? It would seem essential if copyright is to truly work.